Published: 10 Dec 12

Hong Kong’s 25 largest accounting firms 2012

Will the new Companies Ordinance improve Hong Kong’s score?

A joint study by CLSA Asia-Pacific Markets and Asian Corporate Governance Association has revealed that cracks in corporate governance have become more obvious elsewhere in the region with most corporate scores either falling or rising marginally this yea compared to 2010 results. Hong Kong is no exception, which saw its score barely rising by one percentage point (ppt) to 66 points. Singapore edged out Hong Kong after scores improved by 2 ppts to 69.

Fair share of scandals

According to ACGA secretary-general Jamie Allen, both Singapore and Hong Kong have had their share of scandals, frauds, and conflicted IPO processes and both lack world-class systems of corporate governance. Singapore however outscored Hong Kong because the former’s government has been focusing greater attention on corporate governance reforms in the past two years. “Singapore has improved regulations and regulatory enforcement. Retail investor engagement is also growing. It also sets the benchmark for the independent regulation of auditors,” he said.

Hong Kong, he adds, continues to outflank Singapore in regulatory enforcement and has also improved some rules and regulations but it still has no sign of any clear government strategy on corporate governance. “Influence remains excessive and there there is no properly independent audit regulator,” he said.

According to this year’s report, the main issue in Hong Kong is audit regulation and audit quality. Hong Kong’s audit quality is said to have deteriorated to 75% in 2012 from 85% in 2010.

Government actions

Davis Polk & Wardwell (DPW) notes that in recent years there have been considerable developments in corporate governance standards applicable to companies listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange (HKEX) and it has now adopted its extensive proposed changes to the corporate governance code and listing rules, most of which took effect in early 2012.

One of the key changes to the Listing Rules – the requirement that independent non-executive directors (INEDs) comprise one-third of a listed company’s board – will take effect on 31 December 2012, and the new rule requiring a mandatory 15 hours of professional training in each financial year for company secretaries will take effect on a staggered basis according to the date of appointment of an individual as company secretary.

A significant number of the revisions are directed at the main actors in the implementation of corporate governance – the directors and the company secretary – and the constitution and responsibilities of various committees of the board. In respect of directors, DPW said that the revisions generally are designed to heighten the level of active participation required from directors such that mere attendance at board meetings is not sufficient.

Last July, the Legislative Council also marked a significant milestone in improving corporate governance when it finally passed into law the revised Companies ordinance. It will come into effect in 2014, and one of the key changes is that there is now a criminal liability on auditors of Hong Kong-incorporated companies if the auditors fail to declare in their audit reports the existence of certain accounting discrepancies or the inability to obtain all information and explanations necessary for the preparation of the audit.

Auditors’ oppositions

The revised law was generally accepted by the Hong Kong public except the auditors. The Hong Kong Institute of CPAs has lobbied against clause 399 which introduced criminal offences on auditors.

Winnie C. W. Cheung, chief executive and registrar of the Institute, said, “The consequence and harm done for the profession and Hong Kong will be huge if the clause is passed. Clause 399 will unduly lower the barriers to prosecution and bring great risks to good people in the profession. Talented young members of the profession will seek other career options with fewer risks and the quality of the profession will suffer.

The Institute’s position is to remove the clause altogether. It has also proposed a way to reduce the damage and alleviate the uncertainty the clause creates. It asked to change the prosecution threshold from “knowingly or recklessly” omitting a required statement from the audit report to making such an omission “dishonestly or with intent to defraud.” The proposed amendments intended to reinforce ACRA’s monitoring of firmwide quality controls and policies will enhance audit quality.

Sign up for our newsletter


Do you know more about this story? Contact us anonymously through this link.

Click here to learn about advertising, content sponsorship, events & rountables, custom media solutions, whitepaper writing, sales leads or eDM opportunities with us.

To get a media kit and information on advertising or sponsoring click here.

Tags: Top accounting firms in Hong Kong, rankings


Subscribe Now
Cash-flush tourists in HK


Is Central Hong Kong a ghost town in the making?


As goes Singapore, so goes Hong Kong?



Hong Kong’s 5 hot new restaurants in September

Hong Kong’s 5 hot new restaurants in September

More international brands made their way into Hong Kong’s F&B industry.

20 Oct 2014 | 1683 views

Check out BASF’s new environment-friendly headquarters

Check out BASF’s new environment-friendly headquarters

The company cuts 50% of its electricity consumption every month through LED lighting.

29 Sep 2014 | 1423 views

Check out HK’s first dining-in-the-dark restaurant

Check out HK’s first dining-in-the-dark restaurant

Experience an actual blind date at the Alchemy in the Dark.

10 Oct 2014 | 1399 views

Take a tour at Hong Kong’s first modern French restaurant

Take a tour at Hong Kong’s first modern French restaurant

And, get to know the three-Michelin-starred Chef behind its creation.

23 Sep 2014 | 1075 views

The Langham Hong Kong completes US$30 million refurbishment

The Langham Hong Kong completes US$30 million refurbishment

Check out the new London-style suites and its award-winning Artesian Bar.

27 Oct 2014 | 944 views

Do you want to build a killer app?

Do you want to build a killer app?

Altitude Labs will make your ideas happen – Silicon Valley-style.

9 Oct 2014 | 666 views

Are you ready for Italian mania? Jamie’s Italian finally hits Hong Kong

Are you ready for Italian mania? Jamie’s Italian finally hits Hong Kong

The new outlet features a bold graffiti mural by the founder’s long-time pal.

3 Nov 2014 | 666 views
close Don't Show Again

STAY INFORMED! Get our free weekly newsletter